The St. Louis Cardinals didn’t have many bright spots in 2025, but their bullpen was one of them. Despite finishing the year with a 78–84 record, their relievers posted a strong 3.74 ERA, ranking 10th in MLB. A major part of that success veteran reliever, who joined the team during spring training and quickly became one of their most reliable arms.
Top star delivered an impressive season, putting up a 2.35 ERA with 48 strikeouts across 38.1 innings before being traded to the Texas Rangers at the deadline. In exchange, St. Louis received pitchers Mason Molina and Skyler Hales, along with international bonus pool money. Remarkably, Maton added velocity in his 30s—something few pitchers manage—and his pitch movement remained elite. Now back on the free-agent market, Maton is reportedly open to returning to St. Louis.
A reunion could make sense for both sides. With JoJo Romero potentially on the trade block and John King a possible non-tender candidate, the Cardinals will need bullpen reinforcements this winter. Maton will likely command more than the $2 million one-year contract he originally signed, and several teams are expected to pursue him after his strong 2025 performance.
Last year Maton was a late-offseason signing, but that won’t be the case this time around. Given the demand for his services, he’s expected to land a deal much earlier, meaning St. Louis can’t afford to drag its feet if it wants him back.
Money will be a factor, as the Cardinals are looking to trim costs. However, Maton grew up in Chatham, Illinois, as a lifelong Cardinals fan and has spoken highly of his stint with the club. That local connection might be enough to convince him to take a team-friendly deal to return home.
If Maton does re-sign with St. Louis and the team struggles again, the Cardinals could move him at the trade deadline—just like they did last year—to acquire more prospects. That possibility could give Maton pause, knowing another midseason trade might be looming.
Still, if the veteran right-hander is willing to sign at a reasonable price, the Cardinals would gladly welcome him back into their bullpen. Even if 2026 turns into another tough year, Maton could provide high-quality innings and serve as a valuable trade asset. He may cost more than the budget-conscious Cardinals prefer, but bringing him back could prove to be a smart investment.