The Philadelphia Phillies are well-positioned to compete for the NL East crown but will need to make key additions at the MLB trade deadline in late July to strengthen their postseason chances. That responsibility falls to team president Dave Dombrowski — and thanks to a recent report by Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, his task may have just gotten easier.
According to Hiles, Pirates outfielder Bryan Reynolds has a no-trade list that includes several contending teams — but notably not the Phillies. Teams Reynolds reportedly would reject a trade to include the Mets, Yankees, Dodgers, Padres, Blue Jays, and Giants. While it’s surprising that a player would turn down moves to several playoff-caliber clubs, Reynolds likely has personal or professional reasons.
Limited trade market for Bryan Reynolds
Reynolds hasn’t had his best season, which is part of the reason Pittsburgh is open to dealing him. That said, his trade value has dipped. Reynolds is locked into a team-friendly contract through 2031, with a maximum salary of $20 million in the final year (a club option). Despite being a reliable player in past seasons — his lowest WAR was 2.51 in 2023 — he’s currently tracking for a negative WAR in 2025 while batting just .229 with a .673 OPS. His average defensive play is the only thing saving him from a completely forgettable season. A fresh start could revitalize his performance — if the Pirates are willing to move him.
Reynolds could address key holes in Philadelphia’s outfield
Philadelphia’s outfield remains a concern. Brandon Marsh may not be suited for an everyday role in center, Nick Castellanos could be traded if the Phillies are willing to include prospects to offload his contract, and Johan Rojas has fallen out of favor with fans. While Reynolds wouldn’t be a blockbuster acquisition anymore, he still has the tools to be a consistent contributor — and potentially offer a long-term solution. His affordable deal only increases his appeal, even if he returns to All-Star form.
Another plus: Reynolds has strong personal ties to Pittsburgh, and a move to nearby Philadelphia wouldn’t be too disruptive. His low-key personality would likely fit well in the Phillies’ clubhouse. More importantly, Reynolds deserves a real shot at contending. He signed long-term with the Pirates hoping for a turnaround that hasn’t materialized, despite emerging stars like Oneil Cruz and Paul Skenes.
While Pittsburgh’s competitive window seems closed for now, Philadelphia’s is very much open — and Reynolds could be a key piece in their pursuit of October glory.