The Atlanta Braves chose to move on from veteran right-hander Charlie Morton this offseason, a decision that sparked mixed reactions among fans. Morton had been a key contributor in Atlanta’s starting rotation in recent years, and many supporters hoped to see him return.
From 2021 to 2024, Morton logged 686.1 innings with the Braves, posting a 3.87 ERA, along with 771 strikeouts and 269 walks—strong numbers for a pitcher in the twilight of his career. Still, his inconsistency during the 2024 season raised concerns, ultimately leading the team to reconsider bringing the 41-year-old back for 2025.
Charlie Morton’s struggles prove the Braves were right to move on
The Orioles took a chance on veteran right-hander Charlie Morton this offseason, signing him to a one-year, $15 million deal. Unfortunately, the move hasn’t panned out as hoped.
Morton is off to a disastrous start, going 0-7 with a staggering 9.38 ERA over 31.2 innings. He leads the majors in earned runs allowed (33) and tops the American League in walks (22). While age—he’s now 41—may be a factor, the extent of his struggles has still come as a surprise.
A closer look at the underlying numbers helps explain the downturn. Morton’s once-elite curveball has fallen off dramatically. According to Statcast, the pitch that used to rank in the 100th percentile now sits in the 1st percentile. Last season, opponents hit just .198 against it. This year, they’re batting .357 with a .667 slugging percentage.
The drop-off has also impacted his groundball rate. After finishing 2024 in the 75th percentile at 47.2%, Morton’s 2025 groundball rate has slipped to the 39th percentile. His breaking run value has fallen from +2 to -7.
Ironically, hitters are struggling against his fastball—batting just .171 off it—even though it averages a modest 93.8 mph. But his secondary stuff has been ineffective, leading to poor overall results.
While Morton remains a respected veteran and clubhouse presence, it’s becoming clear that time may finally be catching up with him.