As the Philadelphia Phillies continue their push to catch the New York Mets in the National League East, they’re exploring every possible way to bolster their roster—including potential reunions with former players or taking chances on reclamation projects.
The need for added pitching depth has become more pressing following José Alvarado’s 80-game suspension for violating MLB’s banned substance policy—a decision that not only sidelines him for most of the regular season but also rules him out for any potential postseason action.
Despite this setback, the Phillies are in a strong enough position that any roster additions must come with clear upside. That standard effectively eliminates the idea of bringing back former Phillies starter. Recently released by the Orioles after failing to secure a rotation spot, top star struggled badly and gave Philadelphia no reason to consider a reunion. He doesn’t offer bullpen value, and with the current starting rotation firmly established, there’s simply no room for him. Any continuation of Gibson’s career will have to happen elsewhere.
Former Philly Starter Has Hit Another Roadblock After Baltimore Release
Given the league’s ongoing demand for experienced starting pitchers, it’s unlikely that Kyle Gibson’s career is over. A rebuilding team might see value in signing him, hoping he can bounce back and become a trade asset. Conversely, a World Series contender could offer him a minor league deal in the hopes he regains some of his past form.
But for the Phillies, there’s no real decision to make. With a stable, effective starting rotation in place, this isn’t the time to revisit old connections. Even with Aaron Nola currently sidelined by an ankle injury, he’s expected back soon and won’t be replaced by Gibson—despite the occasional frustrations surrounding Nola’s consistency.
Philadelphia should absolutely keep exploring rotation upgrades if the right opportunity arises, but their buy-low focus should be directed toward the bullpen and outfield. The Mets are keeping the pressure on in the NL East, and the looming threat of the Dodgers in October adds to the urgency. Every possible improvement should be considered—but Kyle Gibson isn’t one of them.