According to CBS Sports’ Garrett Podell, the Minnesota Vikings have the fourth-worst quarterback situation heading into the 2025 NFL season, ranking just ahead of the Browns, Colts, and Steelers. Podell points out that while the Vikings selected J.J. McCarthy 10th overall with hopes he’ll be their long-term starter, there’s uncertainty around his readiness following a meniscus tear during the 2024 preseason. Head coach Kevin O’Connell has expressed optimism but also revealed the team explored signing Aaron Rodgers, which Podell suggests is not a strong vote of confidence in McCarthy.
However, I disagree with that assessment. O’Connell and the Vikings are clearly optimistic about McCarthy’s future, largely based on what he demonstrated during the offseason before his injury. Despite missing his rookie year, McCarthy stayed engaged and focused on developing mentally, and O’Connell has said the team expects him to “hit the ground running” this spring. His endorsement of McCarthy as a potential franchise quarterback was enthusiastic, not lukewarm.
The team did consider Rodgers, but that seemed more out of respect than serious intent. Letting Sam Darnold walk and ultimately passing on Rodgers suggests the Vikings believe McCarthy is ready to lead this talented, veteran-heavy roster. He also has the support of his teammates, which is a good sign.
Behind McCarthy, Minnesota has a competent backup in Sam Howell, who started every game for Washington in 2023 and showed promise, despite struggling behind a poor offensive line. Brett Rypien and Max Brosmer add depth to the room as well.
Of course, this isn’t a proven quarterback group—McCarthy has yet to play a regular-season snap. But with strong coaching, an improved offensive line, top-tier skill players, and a tough defense, the situation is well set up for McCarthy to thrive. While it’s fair not to rank this QB room too high until he proves himself, placing them as the fourth-worst in the league feels too harsh. I’d definitely rate them ahead of teams like the Titans, Jets, and Saints—if not a few others as well.