The Philadelphia Phillies are tightening their hold on the National League playoff race, posting one of the best records in baseball since Don Mattingly took over as manager and establishing themselves as a legitimate World Series contender.
While much of the attention has focused on Philadelphia’s resurgence, a recent series against Toronto brought renewed focus to Mattingly’s previous role as a bench coach for an American League pennant winner. During that stretch, Mattingly reflected on last season’s heartbreaking Game 7 loss to Los Angeles, and in the process offered pointed thoughts about a former Blue Jays star still adjusting to a new situation.
That spotlight has fallen on Bo Bichette, who entered the 2026 season with enormous expectations after leaving Toronto to sign a blockbuster deal with New York. Instead of spearheading a smooth playoff push, the veteran shortstop has become a focal point of criticism as his new team continues to struggle for consistency.
Even so, many around the game believe Bichette’s issues are temporary. Observers note that this is not a proven hitter who has suddenly forgotten how to produce. He hit .311 last season and owns a .294 career average. His slow start has been compounded by an injury-depleted lineup, with key stars missing time due to calf issues, and the pressure of mounting losses has only intensified the challenge of adjusting to a bigger market.